data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bd997/bd9972eb2730039d82078d3f9d406980362f1873" alt=""
"I was dating all these younger guys. I was like, 'Maybe I need to change it up a little,'" she said. "[Jesse] was the one [eHarmony] sent me. It just felt familiar," says Carrie Ann. "In his picture, I felt like I already knew him. He took a risk because he didn't know what I looked like or anything." After months of exchanging e-mails - and still not showing Jesse what she looked like or revealing who she was - Carrie Ann took the plunge.
"A few months later, I finally sent a picture. [It was] me in Hawaii with no makeup," she continued. "We finally went out [on] a supervised date. We went over to my friend's house. It was awesome!" The pair have been engaged since March, but wedding bells are not ringing just yet. Carrie Ann says there's no hurry and in fact, they are trying for a baby instead.
![]() |
Carrie Ann Inaba engaged with Jesse Sloan |